When does 'innovate or die' stop being strategy and start being theater?

3 moonshots got funded last year. All three died by Q4.

Meanwhile our boring API migration cut release time 40%. Nobody clapped. Just numbers moving.

Leadership still says urgency. I see theater. New products fail at rates between 40% and 90%. The 9x Effect (from Gourville’s 2006 HBR paper) explains why: the people building the new product and the people being asked to switch to it are using wildly different scales to measure ‘better.’ That matches what I watched, per the 9x Effect breakdown.

S&P average tenure fell from 33 years to 14-15. Still not a plan.

How do you kill the moonshot circus without looking like you oppose innovation?

All three died by Q4.

nah. post-it was failed 3m glue in 1968. kill that too?

post-it was failed 3m glue in 1968. kill that too?

The post-it is survivorship bias used to defend every moonshot. Silver made the adhesive in 1968, Fry had the idea in 1974, then 3M test-marketed it in 1977 as Press 'n Peel in four cities and it flopped before launch on April 6 1980. That is twelve years, not a hackathon win. I saw this lottery logic at Coinbase. CoinGecko counted 11.6 million dead crypto tokens in 2025, 53.2 percent of all GeckoTerminal listings dead. How many failures should one post-it excuse?